Alternatively, paraconsistent logic is the subfield of logic that is concerned with studying and developing paraconsistent or inconsistencytolerant systems of logic inconsistencytolerant logics have been discussed since at least 1910 and arguably much earlier, for example in. Thus, if a consequence relation is paraconsistent, then even in circumstances where the available information is inconsistent, the consequence relation does not explode into triviality. Paraconsistent logics are those which permit inference from inconsistent information in a nontrivial fashion. Paraconsistent logic stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Someone reasoning with a paraconsistent logic can begin with inconsistent premisessay, a moral dilemma, a kantian. Postulates for paraconsistent reasoning and fault tolerant logic programming. Their articulation and investigation is a relatively recent phenomenon, even by the standards of modern logic. Such programs were called generally horn programs ghps, for. But you can follow any of the programming books and there you will get better logic. Constructive negations and paraconsistency trends in logic.
Part of the lecture notes in computer science book series lncs. This is only meant as a rough aid to intuition, and. It provides logical foundations for annotated logics, discusses some interesting applications of these logics and also includes the. The paraconsistent logics are those, which admit consistent but nontrivial theories, i. Strong completeness results for paraconsistent logic. Strong completeness results for paraconsistent logic programming howard a. People saying that there are contradictions everywhere, without any rational support, and that paraconsistent logic is therefore our salvation, are similar to people alerting about a terrible. This book presents some of the latest applications of new theories based on the concept of paraconsistency and correlated topics in informatics, such as pattern recognition bioinformatics, robotics, decisionmaking themes, and sample size. After proving some basic results about this logic, we show the connection with modalities. Kazumi nakamatsu this book is written as an introduction to annotated logics. Common sense for concurrency and strong paraconsistency. Paraconsistent logic programs with fourvalued rough sets. Such a logic is in a certain sense a minimal paraconsistent logic. The central idea of the book is to show how annotated logic can be applied as a tool to solve problems of technology and of applied science.
Undulatory theory with paraconsistent logic part ii. Paraconsistent logic is a eld of research based on the distinction between contradiction and triviality. Historically speaking, paraconsistency and dialetheism have been common themes in indian logic, especially jainist and buddhist logic. Many systems of paraconsistent logics have been developed, and they are now applied to several areas including. In a non paraconsistent logic, inconsistency explodes in the sense that if a contradiction obtains, then everything everything. This book is the first in the field of paraconsistency to offer a comprehensive overview of the subject, including connections to other logics and applications in information processing, linguistics, reasoning and argumentation, and. To model inconsistent and incomplete information we use a fourvalued logic. Paraconsistent logics like paola zizzis lq and lnq or sambin et als basic logic are useful for describing the lowest common denominators of logical elements of families or categories of stricter logics.
We may even say, as da costa does, that if the strength of this principle is restricted in a system of logic, then the system belongs to the class of paraconsistent logics. I recently listened to an interview with graham priest about paraconsistent logic but still remain unconvinced that there is any good reason to question the principle of noncontradiction. It is a powerful tool for reasoning under contradictoriness as it investigates logic systems in which contradictory information does not lead to arbitrary conclusions. But, the layman will also take profit from its reading. In this paper, we use a paraconsistent logic lfi1 as the underlying logic for the specification of pdatalog, a deductive query language for databases containing inconsistent information. Put differently, a paraconsistent logic is one in which the schema ex contradictione quodlibet. What are the best books for improving programming logic.
Walter carnielli, marcelo esteban coniglio, paraconsistent logic. Paraconsistent logic does not endorse the principle of explosion ex contradictione quodlibet, nor anything which validates it notice the subtly different wording. Fuzzy multicriteria decisionmaking using neutrosophic sets. Logic, epistemology, and the unity of science book 40 thanks for sharing. Thus, paraconsistent logic accommodates inconsistency in a. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves. Priest et al 1989 is a classic early collection of papers. A paraconsistent approach for knowledge base integration allows keeping inconsistent information and reasoning in its presence.
The continuity of tg together with standard techniques of recursion theory yields that the definite part of each tat n, and hence the definite part of tgt cis recursively enumerable. This book gives an overview of paraconsistent logics that is logics which allow for inconsistency. A paraconsistent logic programming approach for querying. This book is the first in the field of paraconsistency to offer a comprehensive overview of the subject, including connections to other logics and applications in information processing, linguistics. The future of paraconsistent logic will depend on a right analysis of the various di. Paraconsistent logic programming 7 intuitively, the annotated atom a. Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. Mar 07, 20 it is recommended reading for anyone interested in the question of reasoning and argumentation in the presence of contradictions, in semantics, in the paradoxes of set theory and in the puzzling properties of negation in logic programming. Anybody with math, programming, or other logical type skills will be able. Handbook of the 5th world congress on paraconsistency. What are the arguments for the necessity of paraconsistent. It will be shown that some of the issues in paraconsistent logic also play a role in logic programming. It is recommended reading for anyone interested in the question of reasoning and argumentation in the presence of contradictions, in semantics, in the paradoxes of set theory and in the puzzling properties of negation in logic programming. What are the arguments for the necessity of paraconsistent logic.
This book is the first in the field of paraconsistency to offer a comprehensive overview of the subject, including connections to other logics and applications in information processing, linguistics, reasoning and argumentation, and philosophy of science. In this paper, we use a paraconsistent logic lfi1 as the underlying logic for the speci. Read paraconsistent intelligentbased systems new trends in the applications of paraconsistency by available from rakuten kobo. Major logic programming language families include prolog, answer set programming asp and datalog. Subrahmanians logics p a deontic logic based on the first of these log ics will be.
The argument ex contradictione quodlibet ecq is paraconsistently invalid. Paraconsistent logics are not, in general, explosive. A most telling reason for paraconsistent logic is the fact that there are theories which are inconsistent but nontrivial. The second part, paraconsistent analysis networks panets, describes the utilization of paraconsistent logic in constructing networks which can deal. Remarks on the applications of paraconsistent logic. A paraconsistent logic is a logic in which it can happen that a contradiction is true, in the sense that both a a and a eg a hold for some proposition a a, without the logic becoming trivial in the sense that all propositions are true. This book presents some of the latest applications of new theories based on the concept of paraconsistency and correlated topics in informatics, such as pattern recognition bioinformatics, robotics, decisionmaking themes, and. Paraconsistent logic internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Each chapter is selfcontained, and an introductory chapter covering the.
This paper also proves that logic programming is not computationally. We present a paraconsistent logic, called z, based on an intuitive possible worlds semantics, in which the replacement theorem holds. May 27, 2005 logic program logic programming operational semantic ground atom paraconsistent logic these keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. But they are also aware that no book of any complexity contains only truths. Part i of this study proved that the paraconsistent annotated logic using two values pal2v, known as the paraquantum logic pql, can represent the quantum by a model comprising two wave functions obtained from interference phenomena in the 2w twowave region of youngs experiment double slit. The future of paraconsistent logic university of neuchatel. In paraconsistent logics the scope of the principle of noncontradiction is, in a certain sense, restricted. Consistency, contradiction and negation english 2016 isbn. A paraconsistent logic is a logical system that attempts to deal with contradictions in a discriminating way. In 32, the authors proposed a logic of multiplevalued argumentation lma, in which agents can argue using multivalued knowledge base in the extended annotated logic programming ealp. When used to model quantum phenomena, pal2v is called paraquantum logic pql.
This book is the first in the field of paraconsistency to offer a comprehensive. A paraconsistent logic is a way to reason about inconsistent information without lapsing into absurdity. Someone reasoning with a paraconsistent logic can begin with inconsistent. The expression was coined by the peruvian philosopher mir o quesada as an answer to newton da costa looking for a good name for the systems he was working on. Paraconsistent intelligentbased systems pdf download for free. Both concepts were developed in the setting of constrictive logic, which explains our choice of the title of the book. Logic program logic programming operational semantic ground atom paraconsistent logic these keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. A theory is inconsistent if there is a formula a grammatically wellformed expression of its language such that the formula and its negation are both theorems of the theory. Paraconsistent mathematics refers to attempts to develop mathematics on top of a foundation of paraconsistent logic and paraconsistent set theory. Paraconsistent intelligentbased systems new trends in. Any program written in a logic programming language is a set of sentences in logical form, expressing facts and rules about some problem domain. Paraconsistent logic is a family of nonclassical logics to tolerate inconsistency. First, we give a semantics for sets of clauses of the syntactic form l 0.
With this model represented in one spatial dimension, we studied in the lattice of the pql. Logical investigations volume 2 by edmund husserl books on. Consistency, contradiction and negation walter carnielli, marcelo esteban coniglio auth. Undulatory theory with paraconsistent logic part i. Priest 2006 is the classic philosophical defense of paraconsistent logic and of dialethism. This book offers a comprehensive guide to the use of neutrosophic sets in multiple criteria decision making problems. Consistency, contradiction and negation walter carnielli,marcelo esteban coniglio this book is the first in the field of paraconsistency to offer a comprehensive overview of the subject, including connections to other logics and applications in information processing, linguistics, reasoning and argumentation, and philosophy of science. Paraconsistent logic comprises a major logical theory and offers the broadest possible perspective on the.
Pdf postulates for paraconsistent reasoning and fault. It shows how neutrosophic sets, which have been developed as an extension of fuzzy and paraconsistent logic, can help in dealing with certain types of uncertainty that classical methods could not cope with. Although allowing for inconsistency, paraconsistent logics are worth considering. It can be represented in the form of paraconsistent annotated logic with annotation of two values pal2v. A logic is paraconsistent iff its logical consequence relation \\vdash\, either semantic or proof theoretic is not explosive. Paraconsistent logic comprises a major logical theory and offers the broadest possible perspective on the debate of negation in logic and philosophy. I have tried searching this subreddit and didnt find anything discussing this. Paraconsistent logics and paraconsistency request pdf. Since nearly half a century various systems of paraconsistent logic have been. Since nearly half a century various systems of paraconsistent logic have been proposed and studied. Paraconsistent logic and artificial intelligencechinese. Logical systems are worth considering in their own right since we can learn about very abstract structural properties of logics and the concepts employed within them such as negation, necessity and consistency. Alternatively, paraconsistent logic is the subfield of logic that is concerned with studying and developing paraconsistent or inconsistencytolerant systems of logic. Paraconsistent logics and paraconsistency university of.
A logical consequence relation is said to be paraconsistent if it is not explosive. However, instead of restricting oneself to such methods, a fullfledged paraconsistent logic can be exploited. In 6, we introduced a means of allowing logic programs to contain negations in both the head and the body of a clause. Paraconsistent mathematics, sometimes called inconsistent mathematics, represents an attempt to develop the classical infrastructure of mathematics e.
On the one hand it provides a paraconsistent approach, based on fourvalued rough sets, for integrating knowledge from different sources and reasoning in the presence of inconsistencies. Paraconsistent intelligentbased systems programmer books. A logic with the property that any formula can be deduced from every set of hypotheses that contains contradictory formulas but one is far from a reasonable paraconsistent logic. Notions of paraconsistent annotated logic pal summarizes the basic theory and fundamentals of the subject.
Paraconsistent logic is the study of logics in which there are some theories embodying contradictions but which are not trivial, in particular in a paraconsistent logic, the ex contradictione sequitur quod libet, which can be formalized as cnt, a,af is not valid. Paraconsistent logic wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Is paraconsistent logic useful or, at least, meaningful. Postulates for paraconsistent reasoning and fault tolerant. Paraconsistent semantics of speech acts sciencedirect. In this work, the concept of pql is applied to create a logical model presenting the fundamental principles of. I have been out of the logic teaching arena for over ten years, but as glynn below suggests there is nothing new in logic. Paraconsistent annotated logics stem from logic programming in the presence. In section 5, we round o the discussion with a summary of the main results. Paraconsistency is a property of a consequence relation. Our framework relates and brings together two major fields.
This book presents some of the latest applications of new theories based on the concept of paraconsistency and correlate. Logic programming is a programming paradigm which is largely based on formal logic. Asenjo 1966 and da costa 1974 develop the logic of paradox based on theor earlier work on paraconsistency in the 1950s. The problems addressed range from methodological issues in paraconsistent and deontic logic to the revision theory of truth and infinite turing machines. A deductive theory is paraconsistent if its underlying logic is paraconsistent. Marcelo e coniglio this book is the first in the field of paraconsistency to offer a comprehensive overview of the subject, including connections to other logics and applications in information processing, linguistics. A number of reformulations of analysis can be developed, for example functions which both do and do not have.
410 882 707 1233 807 1542 161 1321 184 1322 274 876 361 495 423 810 317 283 33 1454 559 1328 664 1074 996 427 600